Ask GeoMan...

What causes the plates to move?

This is another one of those questions in geology that we may never know an answer to FOR SURE. Lots of mechanisms have been proposed (and rejected), but one thing is nearly certain - whatever the force, it's got to be REAL powerful.

Let's play with some approximate numbers. Assume that average continental crust has a density of approximately 2.75 time the density of water. If a cubic foot of water weight 62.4 pounds, this means that each cubic foot of continental crust weighs about 170 pounds. How big is North America? Since we're just trying to get an "order of magnitude" number here, let's assume that on average it's approximately 2500 miles from east to west, 5000 miles from north to south, and 35 miles thick. Let's see... converting all of it to feet that makes (1.3 X 107 feet) times (2.6 X 107 feet) times (1.9 X 105 feet) which equals 6.4 X 1019 cubic feet, times 170 pounds equals 1.1 X 1022 pounds. In normal numbers this is the same as 11,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 pounds (11 sextillion pounds). Okay, nudge it 2 centimeters to the west, please!

With this much mass we can start to rule out some possibilities. The gravitational attraction of the moon just doesn't do the job. Nor does the attraction of the sun. Centrifugal force from the rotation of the earth probably can't get it done, and I really doubt that it's 3 big guys with a rope.

Probably the most logical place to look is inside the earth. We already know that it's pretty hot down there, and we also know that heat and density are related. The short version is that when something is heated up, there is a corresponding decrease in density, and the material rises. This is the reason hot air balloons work, and why the cold water is near the bottom of the lake and not on top. This process also drives the major wind patterns. Rock is no different, and when heated it lowers in density and wants to go up. So far so good. The problem is that if it rises it's going to leave a void where it was, and we sure can't have that. Just like in the lake (or the atmosphere), water, air, or in this case rock, moves in from the side to fill the hole. But that just leaves another hole, so something has to move in to fill that one, and so on and so on until the stuff which moved in the first place does the filling and the circle is complete.

We call this circular pattern of density driven material a "convection cell," and as I said it's this convection which powers the major global wind patterns, affects the ocean currents... and may well drive the plates. Deep beneath the crust the rock is VERY hot, and while there is probably too much pressure for it to be a liquid, it's still somewhat mobile, and individual atoms and such can kinda/sorta ooze about, setting up convection cells which may carry the plates along where they rub up against the surface crust.

Most geologists accept convection currents as the most likely mechanism for plate motions. One of the biggest questions now relates to how deep within the mantle the convection cells extend. Pictured below is a diagram of "Deep Mantle Convection." Many geologists favor this concept. Many others favor shallow mantle convection. Others postulate multiple layers of convection. And I know 3 big boys in Grants Pass who are still looking for a rope.




Click here to ask GeoMan a question

Return to Ask GeoMan's Index of Questions

Return to GeoMan's Home Page


You are GeoManiac number since April 1, 1997