How can I tell the difference between quartz and white feldspar in identifying rocks?
- Geri, Grade 5
Great question. Unfortunately, it can be very difficult to tell them apart sometimes, especially when they are both white. The best clues I use relate to how the minerals grow, and then break.
Feldspar grows (when allowed to) into rectangular crystals, and then usually breaks the same way. This breakage pattern is called cleavage, and feldspar has two directions of cleavage that meet at close to a 90 degree angle (just like a stairway). If you see little sparkles when you look at the rock, the flashes may be the light reflecting off the mirror-like cleavage surfaces.
Quartz has no cleavage (it breaks with a conchoidal fracture - just like obsidian, or the curved fractures that you can often see in the windshield of your car after a rock hits it), so usually no mirror-like flashes of light. The bad news is that sometimes the curved conchoidal surfaces can flash as well, but this usually happens with the clear varieties of quartz (which you already know isn't feldspar anyway).
So, if the mineral has cleavage and sparkles, it may be feldspar. If no sparkles, no matter how you rotate it in the light, it may be quartz.
Hope this helps, and keep looking at the rocks. This earth is the only one we have, and all of us need to treat it with respect and the highest level of responsibility we can - the Golden Rule has never been more important!
Click here to ask GeoMan a question
Return to Ask GeoMan's Index of Questions
Return to GeoMan's Home Page